By DERRICK GINGERY
dgingery@nwherald.com
CARPENTERSVILLE – The District 300 school board does
not have enough impartial members to decide the ethics
case against colleague Mary Warren.
And the district now must wait for a decision from
the Illinois Attorney General's office to determine
whether a three-person ethics commission can decide the
case instead of the board.
This is the first time a school board has applied the
new state ethics law.
Warren was accused of breaking the law when she was
involved in a survey about a potential property-tax
referendum conducted earlier this summer. A complaint
filed by a resident states that Warren introduced the
survey committee to the political action committee that
paid for the survey and asked district employees to
provide information for the survey.
The school board by law must determine whether Warren
violated the ordinance.
As a sitting board member, Warren is required by
state law to remain impartial on political matters,
meaning she cannot advocate for a referendum.
However, three board members – Anne Miller, Mary
Fioretti and President John Court – will be called to
testify at the hearing, district lawyer Darcy Kriha
said.
That leaves only Susie Kopacz and Vice President
Richard Traub to make the decision, which is fewer than
the four board members required to legally take action.
Kriha proposed that the board create a three-person
ethics commission to hear the evidence and decide
whether Warren broke the law. The change would remove
the school board from the process.
"They [board members] want to move ahead the best
they can," Kriha said. "We're trying to handle this in a
way that makes sense."
The board on Monday approved implementing the new
ethics procedure for cases when the board does not have
a quorum.
Kriha said the attorney general must issue a formal
legal opinion on the idea, but she said preliminary
conversations with state officials indicated the process
will be approved.
The formal attorney general opinion could come in 30
days.
Officials from state Attorney General Lisa Madigan's
office could not be reached for comment.
Kriha said the ethics commission would include Traub,
Julie Vallejo, associate superintendent in the Kane
County Regional Office of Education, and Richard Majka
of Educational Management Consulting Inc. Kriha said
Majka is a lawyer and retired assistant superintendent
in Elgin School District 46.
District 300 Superintendent Ken Arndt said he was
comfortable with a majority of the commission not being
affiliated with the district.
"I don't have a problem with that," he said. "They're
reputation speaks highly [of them]."
The commission will have a hearing and then can take
up to 45 days to issue a decision. If the panel finds an
intentional violation, the matter would be referred to
the Kane County State's Attorney's Office.
Violating the state ethics law is a misdemeanor,
punishable by up to a year in jail.
None of the ethics commission's hearings would be
open to the public nor subject to the Illinois Open
Meetings Act, Kriha said. She said the written decision
would be a document open for public
inspection.